Navigating the Morality of AI in Resume Writing

In partnership with

The current job market is an ocean of talent, and candidates face unprecedented competition and scrutiny. In this landscape, artificial intelligence is rapidly becoming the lifebuoy many job seekers cling to as they navigate everything from resume scanning software to automated interview scheduling. But with AI’s hand in nearly every aspect of hiring, we have to ask ourselves: Is it ethical when job candidates use AI to craft resumes that are sometimes too polished? Or is it a necessary adaptation to a flawed system driven by tech-heavy recruitment processes? Job seekers who understand better than most the balance between automation and authenticity have a unique perspective on this debate.

The State of the Job Market: Survival of the Fittest Algorithm
The job market is saturated, and hiring budgets are tighter with companies facing the pressures of post-pandemic economic recovery. According to recent reports, applicants are often up against hundreds, if not thousands, of resumes. Companies turn to applicant tracking systems (ATS) that filter resumes using algorithms and AI-driven keyword scanning to expedite hiring. Many candidates feel pressured to "hack" these systems by using AI to craft ATS-optimized resumes, embedding keywords that help them rise to the top of the virtual pile.

The Ethics of AI in Resume Writing: Ne’er-Do-Wells or New Realities?
At its core, the ethical concern hinges on a question of authenticity. Resumes have traditionally reflected one’s experience, character, and skills. With AI-generated resumes, however, we’re seeing a new breed of resumes—ones precisely engineered to align with job descriptions, sometimes to a point where they reflect an idealized version of the candidate. This can potentially lead hiring managers to a deceptive portrayal of the candidate’s skills. Yet, the decision to use AI tools doesn’t always come from a place of trickery. For many job seekers, it's a desperate attempt to level the playing field.

Casting Light on Desperation: Why Candidates Turn to AI
The unspoken reality is that only some have the resources to hire professional resume writers or get feedback from their field mentors. Candidates using AI aren’t necessarily trying to game the system; they’re trying to survive in it. A 2023 survey on LinkedIn showed that job seekers often spend hours, if not days, tailoring resumes for each job application, leading to burnout and defeat when responses are scarce. AI is a way to cut down this grueling work, creating a glimmer of hope for candidates struggling to find employment.

The B2B Perspective: What Executives Can Learn from This Trend
For professionals, where authenticity is highly prized, this conversation provides a valuable lesson in understanding both sides of the story. While candidates may appear as “ne’er-do-wells” gaming the system, many are simply trying to make it through a system that has made hiring more transactional than ever. From a leadership perspective, this trend points to greater transparency in hiring processes and perhaps even a reevaluation of how AI is employed on both sides of the resume exchange. In an industry where value is built on trust, understanding the motivations behind AI-aided resumes can inform better hiring practices that resonate with the core values of integrity and empathy.

A Call for Balance: Honesty with Empathy in Hiring
AI in resume writing is here to stay, but business leaders can influence the ethical evolution of hiring practices. By developing hiring processes that are fair and transparent—and by considering candidates as people rather than profiles—executives can foster a job market that respects authenticity while acknowledging the realities of AI’s impact.

The morality of using AI in resume writing doesn’t have an easy answer. Candidates’ needs for fairness and companies’ needs for authenticity are constantly balancing on a precarious edge. For executives, the key takeaway is this: a genuine hiring process starts with empathy. By understanding the motives that drive candidates to turn to AI, we can build recruitment practices that better reflect the balance between technological advancement and the human side of hiring.

Unlock the full potential of your workday with cutting-edge AI strategies and actionable insights, empowering you to achieve unparalleled excellence in the future of work. Download the free guide today!